There is a kind of woman I cannot respect. In fact, I loathe her like a cockroach. She is the kind of woman that takes one look at you then shuts down, clinging tightly to her man or muttering viciously in her friend’s ear.
I do not understand her.
I am not by nature a jealous person (although I have felt jealousy on occasion) and I am not a possessive person at all. Perhaps my lack of these characteristics limits my capacity for empathy, but the instant antipathies of some women toward other women and their active aggression based solely on looks are inexcusable. At least, I have never been able to find an excuse for it.
The Last Psychiatrist wrote an analysis recently of the research behind a Live Science article which has been getting some attention in the blogosphere, Eyes Can’t Resist Beautiful People. In it, he discusses these research results…
…women attributed good looking women’s success to luck, and less attractive women’s success to ability; but thought good looking men succeeded because of ability, not luck. Men did the exact same (respectively): good looking men succeeded through luck, good looking women through ability.
This is called the sexual attribution bias, and it’s negative, not positive- i.e. it is specifically about devaluing the good looking rival, not about making correct judgments about the less attractive. And it depends nearly entirely on what extent you think you are more or less attractive than the other person.
“Sexual attribution bias” might sound like jargon but it succinctly describes the reason these women I loathe call other women (and sometimes me) bitch and bimbo and slut and I will reiterate that most important point:
It depends nearly entirely on what extent you think you are more or less attractive than the other person.
What that means to me is that it depends entirely on your confidence in yourself.
Flying in the face of the contemporary wisdom from evolutionary psychology which gets so much coverage in the press these days, attractiveness is not universally quantifiable by measuring symmetry, or homogeneity or waist-to-hip ratio or menstrual cycles. It is not a limited resource handed out sparingly in our DNA. It is not immutable. Even the “plainest” woman can be stunning and even the most “beautiful” women in the world have ugly days; days when they slub around home in their pyjama pants with greasy hair and overgrown eyebrows.
Think about those women you consider most beautiful. Are they all “classical beauties”, or do some of them have “interesting” faces? Do you know what they look like when they are not dressed up, when they have no make-up on, when their hair hasn’t been done? Do they have dry skin on their elbows, shadows or lines under their eyes, breasts that hang a little lower than they used to, silvery stretch marks on their hips and thighs? Of course they do.
Think about your most beautiful girlfriend on her worst days, when what she sees in the mirror and what you see are completely different. Think about those conversations where she enumerates all her imperfections and you see them yet they do not detract from her attractiveness.
And think about that woman you know who has everything in all the right places but leaves you completely cold, that woman a man might fuck but wouldn’t bother giving a second thought to.
I have a friend who is a photographer. He told me a story about a gorgeous actress that he really wanted to shoot and how he had picked on another photographer who had worked with her several times because his photos were always flat. Why were the photos so bad when she was so beautiful? He met her while in California for Herb Ritts’ funeral and knew why within a couple of seconds: Because there was nothing there.
The quality of beauty is not dependent on the raw material you have been blessed with at birth. Consistently attractive women all have a certain sort of ease in the way they inhabit their skin: they do not all have the most even features or the most perfect proportions or the most flawless complexion. They have a magnetism which transcends their physicality, they have the ability to communicate their emotions powerfully and to make others feel recognised.
Even in photos, beauty is more about the content of our characters than some people realise. In real life, it is entirely dependent on it. Our perception of someone’s attractiveness changes as we interact with them.
In my experience the women who are hateful - the ones who talk nastily behind my back, or the ones who determinedly ignore me, or the strangers who say derogatory things over-loudly when I’m out, or the ones who literally slam doors in my face - are usually not physically uglier than me. Usually, their raw materials are on par.
Nonetheless, the woman who calls me a stuck up bitch or a whore before she has even met me is uglier than me and, unlike her, I have a real reason for my disrespect. The content of her character is not pretty.
I can understand insecurity, I really can. I had an eating disorder for many years. What I cannot understand is why some women project their insecurity onto others, why they invest their energy in resentment, why they relish cutting other women down. Even while my eating disorder was getting the best of me, I knew somewhere in the back of my mind that my focus on my appearance was a way of avoiding the real issues I needed to deal with. Even while I loathed myself, it was never in comparison to others. And I never took it out on others.
Again, perhaps my ability to empathise is limited by my character. I internalise, attribute blame or responsibility to myself. Some people externalise and attribute blame and responsibility to others. Both of these processes can be pathological but in the absence of human perfection, internalising problems hurts only you and when you conceptualise something as your responsibility, the concept of being able to do something about it comes along for the ride. Externalising, on the other hand, gives you permission to harm others while denying your own accountability.
It offends my moral compass.
It is also mind-boggling. Why do these women do this to themselves? It is so completely self-defeating. There is no explanation for taking pleasure in cutting others down to size, except to make yourself feel bigger but, like a dog raising its hackles, it is only a surface illusion. It begs the question, Why do they need to feel bigger? If a confident woman is a sexy woman, these women are way behind the 8 ball. Not only do they have no self-confidence, they lack the prerequisite for it: Self-awareness.
And self-awareness, in my opinion, is a moral imperative. I was taught that honesty is the most important, and the best, quality a person can have. Throughout my life I have come to learn that honesty is not about telling people the truth, it is about rigorously trying to know the truth. About yourself. It is only through that real humility and real pride that you can judge other people fairly.
I don’t expect everyone to like me - there are natural antipathies and I have as many failings as the next person - but women who hate me for my cleavage or my lipstick are cockroaches in my estimation. With my best understanding, I can judge them fairly as not worthy of my notice or my respect.
It has been a while since I have experienced this - I have been out of the loop socially - but when I move back into the city and see my friends again (including the ones whose girlfriend’s haven’t had a conversation with me in all the years they’ve been “the girlfriend”) I wonder if things will be different. I’m older now (34) and 10 kilos heavier, but I still take pleasure in playing dress-ups and I enjoy being comfortable in my skin (I’ve earned that!) so I don’t think things will have changed very much. I think I will still be on the receiving end of the sexual attribution bias every now and then.
But perhaps I am missing something. Perhaps the people who read this and the people who know me can offer an alternative explanation for why these women behave the way they do, one that excuses them. Perhaps I can yet be moved to empathise. Empathy is always preferable.
Tell me, who exactly is the bitch here?
Related Posts